Word from a US soldier

Esther Ewing EwingChange at aol.com
Fri Feb 11 12:26:37 PST 2005



Judy:
Why did you put "fact" in quotes?

Chris,
Thanks for all of your insights and great discussions!!   Good food for
thought.  I, too, agree that this soldier's note is a  very small piece of
the whole puzzle.......BUT......I, personally, still  conclude (not based
solely on his email but on many other learned factors)  that Iraq is a more
"open" society than it was.  Do I think it's a  great, safe place to live?
Definitely not but at least their society, as a  whole, is headed in a better
direction.  As HO says, the Iraqi's now  have an opportunity to take the
future into their own hands.  It is a  "fact" that they did not have that
opportunity a few years  ago.
Judy

I don't have any great answers for the questions you have  at the end of your
message...that's what I'm learning from all of  you.
Thanks again for your intriguing words.

----- Original Message  -----
From: "Chris Corrigan" <chris.corrigan at gmail.com>
To:  <OSLIST at LISTSERV.BOISESTATE.EDU>
Sent: Friday, February 11, 2005 1:36  AM
Subject: Re: Word from a US soldier


> Finding myself  witnessing this exchange, and using it to practice
> asking some  questions:..
>
>
>> I agree with you that force was used  to open the space which is obviously
>> not an OST principle (but I  don't think that means that the space can't
>> be
>>  're-opened').  I disagree that it started with lies but that's  a
>> political
>> debate and not one of open space, so I  won't go there.  As for 'US style
>> Democracy' being the only  choice, who's making the decisions as to how
>> Iraq
>> will  operate in the future?...the Iraqi's.  I think their space is  open
>> to
>> let the majority of the Iraqi people  decide...that's why the voting
>> turnout
>> was so  good.  I believe the U.S. will eventually "let go" of the  outcome
>> so
>> this doesn't just 'close the space' in my  eyes.  Again, this difference
>> of
>> opinion can be  another political debate and I don't intend to do that in
>> this  forum...but will gladly have a constructive debate one-on-one, if
>>  you'd
>> like.
>>
>
> The question for me always  in working with a community is not "is the
> space open or not?"   Space is always open, even a little.  The bigger
> question is "how  can we open more space here?"  If you have a
> situation where  there is violent conflict, you need more space.  Iraq
> is not a  peaceful place at the moment.  That tells me that space wants
> to  be cleaved open even further.  If it is your feeling that the
>  United States should not leave Iraq for a while, then we might ask
>  "what is the most space we can open here together?"  If you think  that
> Iraq should be able to do fine on its own, then, as an American  you
> might ask "where can we let go some more?"  But if, in this  situation,
> I really wanted to open space, I might ask "what if we had  peace now
> and what if together we created that?  What would we  have to do to
> stop the violence and sustain a peaceful civil society  in Iraq?  What
> might our roles be here on the ground to bring  peace to life?"
> Something like that.  For sure I would encourage  talking rather than
> fighting.  I believe that most people would  choose even banal
> constitutional conferences to killing one  another.  So if we are still
> killing one another, what is the  space that we can open to be bigger
> than the killing  impulse?
>
>> Thanks for your kind words about this  soldier.  I only wanted to share
>> the
>> story to  those interested in seeing it from an angle that isn't always
>>  easy
>> to get.  An even more interesting thing is that this  soldier admits that
>> he
>> had doubts about the war before  arriving in Iraq.  Here's a blurb from
>> another message from  him:
>>     "When I was first coming over here I had  my own inner personal doubts
>> about the war, but after being over  here and seeing, hearing,
>> experiencing
>> what I  have,     it's changed.  They never tell you on the media  about
>> the
>> nearly 400,000 up-to-date immunizations that  children now have, or a
>> continually improving  and
>>     much needed sewage system, or the fact that  school books don't
>> portray
>> Saddam as a God anymore and  that girls are now allowed in schools.  They
>>   don't tell you that the US Army is paying for any damages to  civil
>> areas
>> we cause AND the ones the insurgents  cause.  They only show US soldiers
>> geting
>>   killed and beating up prisoners."
> > Sounds more open  to me than it was when Saddam was in power....it's no
>> longer a  country that has "no choices"...
>> Judy
>
> He's one  voice.  That's his story.  It's great but it's hardly enough
>  to give us a picture of life in Iraq.  I find that in North  America,
> we are often guilty of judging an entire complex situation  with a
> sound bite.  This type of debate is very common, and  supported by our
> culture of punditry, where the goal is to talk and  listen to debate
> and win a point rather than to incur deeper  understanding of one
> another's positions and interests.  And so  pundits invoke sound bites
> like this and draw wild conclusions about a  situation based on a small
> fact.
>
> Whether that sound  bite comes through TV or through a forwarded email
> of a soldier, it's  just a small small small piece of story.  I can't
> judge the  health of civil society in Iraq based on what he said.  This
>  report tells me that there are 400,000 immunized children, new sewers,
>  new text books AND much damage to civil areas and death and beaten up
>  prisoners.  That sounds complex, messy, full of guesses, rounding
>  errors and assmuptions.  I can't possibly read that and draw
>  conclusions about how open Iraqi society is now compared to three
>  years ago.  And, I assume, as this soldier showed up in Iraq only
>  after the war started, I'd be surprised if he could make an accurate
>  comparison either.  He can share his story though, and that's  fine,
> for what it's worth.
>
> I think it's not easy to  say whether THIS Iraq has more or less
> choices than THAT Iraq.   Perhaps you have gained the right to vote,
> but you have lost a  constant power supply.  Perhaps you have immunized
> kids but no  husband any more.  Maybe you no longer live in fear of the
> secret  police, but you are now afraid of being accidentally shot or
> bombed to  death.  I don't know.  I don't believe one man, even if he
>  is in the middle of this, can really know how Iraqis feel.  I  would
> bet that it's not as simple as "it's more open."
>
>  Given this report and this curious email exchange on the OSLIST how
>  can we practice holding open judgement and suspending conslusions?
> As  Open Space facilitators what is our responsibility with respect to
>  witnessing this situation?
>
> It's a complex world and these are  complex questions.
>
> Chris
>
>  -------------------------
> CHRIS CORRIGAN
> Consultation -  Facilitation
> Open Space Technology
>
> Weblog:  http://www.chriscorrigan.com/parkinglot
> Site:  http://www.chriscorrigan.com
>
> *
> *
>  ==========================================================
>  OSLIST at LISTSERV.BOISESTATE.EDU
> ------------------------------
>  To subscribe, unsubscribe, change your options,
> view the archives of  oslist at listserv.boisestate.edu:
>  http://listserv.boisestate.edu/archives/oslist.html
>
> To learn  about OpenSpaceEmailLists and OSLIST FAQs:
>  http://www.openspaceworld.org/oslist

*
*
==========================================================
OSLIST at LISTSERV.BOISESTATE.EDU
------------------------------
To  subscribe, unsubscribe, change your options,
view the archives of  oslist at listserv.boisestate.edu:
http://listserv.boisestate.edu/archives/oslist.html

To  learn about OpenSpaceEmailLists and OSLIST  FAQs:
http://www.openspaceworld.org/oslist





Esther Ewing
The Change Alliance
330 East 38th St., Suite  53K
New York, NY 10016, USA
Telephone: 212-661-6024, Fax:  866-296-6712

Assisting organizations to build capability
_www.changealliance.com_ (http://www.changealliance.com/)
Certified Panoramic Feedback Distributor (360  instrument)
_www.panoramicfeedback.com_ (http://www.panoramicfeedback.com/)
Certified Kolbe Distributor: _www.kolbe.com_ (http://www.kolbe.com/)

*
*
==========================================================
OSLIST at LISTSERV.BOISESTATE.EDU
------------------------------
To subscribe, unsubscribe, change your options,
view the archives of oslist at listserv.boisestate.edu:
http://listserv.boisestate.edu/archives/oslist.html

To learn about OpenSpaceEmailLists and OSLIST FAQs:
http://www.openspaceworld.org/oslist
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openspacetech.org/pipermail/oslist-openspacetech.org/attachments/20050211/05a447f5/attachment-0016.htm>


More information about the OSList mailing list